1 day ago
Game Day Session 2: DM FAILURE
Game day, Session 2 was horrible on my part. I had one goal,
and that was to playtest a mass combat system that I had floating around in my
brain for several months. We had some loose ends to tie up; the party was
chasing the surviving orcs which I had set up as an old-fashion gulch shoot
out. We really needed miniatures, but I refused, and instead ended up having to
describe the same battlefield 4 times per round, it turned into a giant mess,
and nothing but a hack-n-slash session where I was rolling for 30 orcs who
couldn’t hit anything unless I rolled a 20. I got bored, of it. My intention
was to slowly introduce more powerful orcs, but we started play with 12th
level characters, a level that is way outside of my comfort level. The result
was chaos and no challenge whatsoever.
I had expected eight players and only five showed. I really
messed up with one character who I thought for sure was going to be there, so I
pregenerated an awesome character, and gave him information that the party
needed to continue the story. . . I know better, I do! I just really thought
that he would show up, so when he didn’t, I had this DM character on my hands
that I really don’t want to play. I reduced his active hit points to bare
minimum, and then got ready for the next encounter, which in my head was
awesome! It was going to be a chase through the Stonelands, I had 20 horses,
each with two orcs. One orc shooting a bow, the other armed with a lance. I
still didn’t want to use miniatures because I didn’t have them ready, so I set
up the dry erase board to use magnets and such, and once I was finished, I
started the encounter and between the Ranger and the Cleric, they used only two
spells to wipe my entire army out before they could even engage them. . .
WHAT!?! The spells, these 12 lvl spells
are kicking my butt and I can’t plan for them! I am totally in over my head, if
I had started the campaign at 1st level, then I could grow as a DM
with the characters, but then I would had lost my story, but I should had
started the party off at first level, because now I have no idea how to prep
for them, but we have reached a decision, the players are going to write down
complete spell lists so that I can have a chance at properly prepping for them.
They want to play at the best of their abilities, and so do I. We haven’t
played at this level for years, and I have never DMed a campaign this high
before. Yes, I know how to do it, but I am just overwhelmed and have become a
slave to the story.
There comes a time when you are just too irritated to
contenue DMing, you know that what you had prepped isn’t going to work, and you
are on the spot. I was sick of throwing dice, and the spells defeating large
armies anyway, so what the hell am I supposed to do?
I wanted to quit, but we only get to play once per month, so
the show must go on, as crappy and as pointless as the show might be, the
horrible thing MUST go on! But I did say, screw it. No role-playing, lets just
jump right into the action! I want to play test the battle system I came up with.
Now according to my story, I had given the players the
option going south to a major city, or east to a border town, and they chose to
go east. My orcs were set to begin their take-over. The major army was taking
the major city to the south, to use as a base of operations for further
conquest, and a smaller weaker army had to prove themselves worthy of joining
by taking out this border town and enslaving the population to work in a mine
that they had taken from mindflayers. The Black Network is still cooperating
with the orcs and had done an excellent job providing intel on exactly how many
troops were protecting the bordertown (850), so they were supplied with a
sufficient number to take it, (1,200), I had originally set up a third aid to
the orcs consisting of a mountain giant acting as a catapult, and
protected by ogres as he bashed the wall
down with bolders, but I nixed it because I wanted to test the battle system
which couldn’t support that.
My original plan was to have the players use armies represented
by poker chips, and use the hit vs. ac method pulled from the 2e Battle System,
which has mechanics that are beyond our level of play. We’ve never played mass
combat or war games beyond the board game RISK. While we were playing the scene
with the mountain giant, we also determine what is happening at the gate by
doing theatre of the mind battles with pokerchips, but by this point I didn’t
want to do that at all, so I nixed the mountain giant and started setting up an
orcish army using the poker chips. It didn’t work, it was just throwing even
more dice and we ended up stopping the game and having a huge brainstorming
session where we are home-brewing our own mass combat game.
We aren’t grognards, we need a game that grows with us so we
are going as basic as one can go. I’ve got 5 different colors of chips to
represent 5 different kinds of troops that can be on the board at once, and
while my original idea was to eliminate movement rules, that has proven to be
impossible. Over all it was a very productive night, but not in the way that I
had intended. I fell on my face, which happens, but I did get the players to
tell me exactly what we want to do.
SO! I am modifying the story. The orcs have taken over their
half of Cormyr and want to take over the other half, which should happen in a
wave. The players are beyond this phase of the game, and instead are going to
investigate the Mine of Sorrow and try to figure out what is going on and close
the mine. At the mine, the orcs are going to be of much higher level, I’m
scrapping the level limits put upon them by the core rules. This game will be
much easier to prep as it provides a better structure. Last game was just get
to town and defend it, and there was no real way for me to even put it into
danger. I had prepped two different armies and, well, I’ll quit whining.
Next game we’ll play an old fashioned hex crawl, that
hopefully leads to a classic dungeon. I’m going to throw all I can at the party
and see what sticks. Episode 2 was a bust :/
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
My Blog List
-
My Shoe is Safe - Yesterday's quiz was a toughie. In it, to recap, commenters were encouraged to guess at what the following pieces of art, generated by Substack's own AI ...
-
Fifth-Edition D&D’s Original Lead Designer Calls Out the Game’s “Secret Error” That Remains Today - In fifth edition Dungeons & Dragons, characters and monsters calculate the difficulty class (DC) number needed to save against their spells and powers usin...4 days ago
-
-
La nuova vita di Dungeons&Dragons versione Mentzer! - Ben ritrovati, di recente mi è capitato di leggere su Facebook un commento che mi ha lasciato attonito. In corrispondenza a un post che pubblicizzava un...
1 week ago -
Who Made Blackmoor? A History of Setting Development - In a sense Blackmoor "grew like Topsy", that is to say wild and on its own. Perhaps the first iteration of anything we might call Blackmoor is the well-d...2 weeks ago
-
Banquet For Fools With Game Developers Hannah And Joseph Williams – Episode 281 – 11/26/2024 - Shane Plays Geek Talk Episode #281 – 11/26/2024 Game developers Hannah and Joseph Williams join to chat about their new “Dark Crystal”-like CRPG Banquet ...3 weeks ago
-
All the holidays, all the prices ... (and some news!) - *The short of it is: all my games are on the cheap from now on until January. It is the season, after all. And while I'm here, I might as well talk a bit...
4 weeks ago -
Grimdark vs. Eucatastrophe - Noisms has some interesting ideas in this post about his desire for some depth to his grimdark, and turns to Gene Wolfe and Tolkien for relief. Now, it ...
6 months ago -
Attronarch's Athenaeum - Over at the forum El Borak mentioned Attronarch in his thread Hirelings, loyalty, and morale which you should take a look at. Attronarch has a website Att...9 months ago
-
Last move - to self-hosting! - As my vote regarding Substack in the “marketplace of ideas”, I’m moving to self-hosting. I’m now at (and hopefully staying for a long time at) Blog: ht...11 months ago
-
It's been a decade, now... - This is a tough time of year for me. So, with your indulgence, here's this link to a post I did a decade ago... EDIT: I have no idea why it didn't take. S...2 years ago
-
This Blog is now on Indefinite Hiatus - Greetings, I haven’t been able to post except sporadically for a while. I just found out I will need to find a new place to live within the next few months...3 years ago
-
RIP Christopher Tolkien - LONDON (AP) – Christopher Tolkien, who played a major role protecting the legacy of his father’s The Lord of the Rings series, has died. He was 95. The Tol...4 years ago
-
Sacrifice in the Perilous Realms - Characters sacrifice consumable goods to gods and demons. Characters specify a particular recipient of sacrifice. Characters must find a suitable altar ...4 years ago
-
The Sprawl Session Recaps - For those interested in Actual Play for my campaign of The Sprawl, a Powered by the Apocalypse cyberpunk RPG by Hamish Cameron, I've made a landing page fo...5 years ago
-
Lake Geneva Original RPG Campaign: New EN World Column: #1 - Lake Geneva Original RPG Campaign: New EN World Column: #1: I am now an author for EN World with a monthly column. Six lead columns have been submitted to...5 years ago
-
Blackmoor Week 2019 (9/24/19) - Blackmoor Week and Dave Arneson Game Day running from September 24th through October 1st. This year 2019 is the 45th anniversary of Dungeons & Dragons and ...5 years ago
-
Dave Arneson Blackmoor Week and Game Day 2019 - Blackmoor Week begins today Sept 24, 2019. What are you doing this week to celebrate Dave Arneson's Birthday and his foundational game setting Blackmoor ak...
5 years ago -
Blackmoor Week Day I 2019 - *Blackmoor Week* kicks off today and concludes on October 1st with *Dave Arneson Game Day*. [image: Dave Arneson’s Blackmoor - B-Ware - Sphärenmeisters Spi...5 years ago
-
Basic Land Cannons: Classic and OSR - Basic Land Cannons Threw together some basic cannon rules for a bit of fun carnage. First up: I'm keeping it simple. Cannons are complicated; there are many...
5 years ago -
Character Concepts: Planescape pt 3 - Part 1 Part 2 Continuing my series on oddball Planescape Faction Personalities... Harmonium Sidby the Stick (LG/halfling/fighter) - Sidby's a good enough b...5 years ago
-
Ravensburg Reboot: Streamlined City Map - I mentioned in my last post how I was tweaking and reworking parts of my Ravensburg setting. Today I streamlined the city map. The old map had lots of redu...
5 years ago -
And Now the News Draft Download on Patreon - It's self-styled Throwback Thursday and *having just released the 34-page draft booklet of Hill Cantons news to my Patreon backers* I am going to indulge m...5 years ago
-
Save Versus All Wands Contest: What is the Value of the Coin Hoard? - Treasure Type H Announcing the third annual (well, not quite) Save Versus All Wands contest! You can read about and see the results of the first two - *...
6 years ago -
NIGHTMARES AND SUBURBS: CHARACTER SOCIAL CLASS TABLE - * CHARACTER SOCIAL CLASS * *BACKGROUND TABLE* *I am a big fan of the “Social Origin Roll” for all my player characters in all my g...6 years ago
-
RPGs, Avatar vs Chess Piece Playing - I've gone from DMing AD&D 1E games for friends to my kids to paying clients as a team building tool. I've seen the approaches of playing a character as an...7 years ago
Links to Suggested Stuff
12 comments:
I guess this is a classic example of never knowing what your players will do, and how your carefully planned story and encounters never hold up to your own plan and vision. While it does seems that you do a good job in keeping the story flexible and sticking to what you planned instead of "cheating" (buffing the orcs/horses mid-play because they died too fast), it's hard not to try and salvage and railroad to your own vision.
One of the hardest thing for me to plan, seems to be the difficulty of the encounters - I don't want my players to feel their deaths are cheap because I throw too powerful monsters at them (Especially if they are trapped in placed, where they have no other options) or that they breeze through without breaking a sweat(/dice? ;)). Good luck adjusting to lvl 12!
Yeah, there is no magic formula. We also play a game that takes place here on earth in the year 1890, when we first rolled up the characters, those guys looked like they they were only fit for role-playing, but I did want to test them, so I pit them up against a nasty grave elemental, it was the perfect battle! The Grave Elemental missed more often then it hit, but when it hit it did nasty things, and it hit just enough to keep things really exciting. The players hits were the same way, they were able to hit it, but not all of the time. It required the use of magic and bravery on the part of players who weren't typically the ones in the front.
I like less monsters; that 30+ monsters per party was for the birds! I am going to have to cheat, and bust the typical level limits which keep the orc in check. I am thinking that the lowest I can go for the common enemy is 8th.
I think that the game prior to this one worked so well because I didn't target the players directly, the orcs goals were to destroy and target weaker characters, I can NEVER allow the normal orcs to actively engage the players, but I can still hurt them by attacking those around them.
I've got to get control back from the players in regards to where to go and what to do as I really need to plan the encounters a lot better.
This just happens from time to time. Not everything you plan out in your head comes to fruition and that's the beauty of the game. Stories get exceptionally frustrating and boring if players are constantly constrained into the choices that the DM had envisioned. Those are typically the campaigns that also devolve into players just trying to break their DMs, from my experience.
As for the spells, I ask for flavor. I like to know the general ideas and thoughts behind their spells, but I would never ask for a specific spell list. Doing so really breaks one of the most fun elements that a PC has at their disposal. As a DM, you get an almost giddy sense of excitement knowing about the giant baddy perched on the ceiling of a dark room. That's a great feeling to have, and part of what makes the game wonderful. PCs have a similar ability, but it's in the slow reveal of their spells and abilities, things they can do to try and reciprocate that same feeling DMs get, except the reveal is for the rest of their party as well as the DM. Even further, players typically have minimal idea with what they are about to face, and that's fine. But even DMs shouldn't be able to know every capability of the party, because we're human. I've seen people, and I've personally picked apart my monsters by how my party could just dissect them, and ended up formulating something that just felt.. metagamey and bad.
I got a good stern talking to by my players; they wanted my insane logic puzzles. I've got a very cerebral group who'd rather think their way through a game. The only way to do that is to know what is going on.
In regards to spell lists, a DM should know exactly what is on your spell lists, that helps us set the difficulty level. I don't have to know what it is that you are going to cast all the time, but I do have to know what spells that you have available to you.
With this particular game, I had set the difficulty for 1-5 level, which is my comfort zone, and the point of the game is to get our of our comfort zones.
For spells, you are entitled to your opinions on them, and running your games as such. I've spent my time about 60/40, majority of which was as a DM.
A DM does not have to know, a DM will make a choice if they want to know. I've only had a small handful of times where it has come out overly difficult because I didn't have such knowledge. If a DM finds it difficult to balance without this knowledge, then by all means use it to better the game. But I personally have not had much difficulty in those regards. My time playing as a player also understands how special that information is to my players as well, so I'm a bit more hesitant to remove a portion of their enjoyment just to make my life slightly easier, personally.
But everyone has differing DM styles, it's what makes the game go 'round.
This topic has come up in the game, and you are making some excellent points. This debate is going on in my head too. I always thought that every DM knew. Do you still make them pick out spells that they want to use in advance? 2e has a huge list of spells to pull from! The reason why I think that the spell list is better is that it keeps the player more engaged in the game, and it is also the same handicap that I have, but I don't cheat, I typically role-play the NPC while choosing the spells. I'm no expert on those things, and I freely admit it. I know the lower leveled spells better, because that is what we have played more often than not, but the more we play at a higher level, the more I'll learn them too. These things are things that we really haven't used in years! Once I get the difficulty adjusted, they will be more fun to explore. I like the idea of rolling with the punches, and I never want the game to turn into an Us vs. the DM thing.
I don't use mass combat. My approach to handling the players in battle is that the players "touch the elephant" see only their own little part of the battlefield, unless that happen to be in the general's tent, in which case, they get to see the sand table, but not boots on the ground.
Another thing I do is, I run an old fashioned campaign, with a beginning, projected trajectory and an end game. The story only changes if the whole party gets killed, then new characters are rolled and a new storyline starts. Part of that ritual is that we only get together when everyone can make it. It takes a toll on me, since I work an early morning shift, but, when we played, we got together once between 3 to six weeks. If someone could not make it, we either cancelled the game or played board games.
Normally I do the same thing, Brooser, but for the current scenario, I'm not sure what will happen, and AD&D is designed to handle some mass combat, it is just getting these rarely used rules to work for us. As long as it's fun, we are doing it right!
Regarding the book-review of the DMG, I remember reading something about highlevel campaigns; It will be more difficult to hurt your PC's physically because they will be so versed and powerful in combat, so it is often better to balance the campaign about hurting their emotions and what they can't control - You mention it yourself, hurt the world and the people around them, and let them fight the situation as a whole, rather than let them take a straight up fight with some orcs.
...Or maybe it's time to conjure up orc-dragons? :D
I know all of this stuff, but I still allowed myself to be unprepared. I can and will fix this, but I didn't want to be one of those Bloggers that make everything out to be perfect, some times even us old veterans of the game fall on our faces too. I'm not proud of it, but it happens, and the only thing that I can do is figure out what went wrong, and rethink what I'm doing.
BTW, you are thinking of DM's Option: High-Level Campaigns; & yeah, I could do with a refresher read.
Yeah, that's what I'm thinking of.
And sometimes you gotta just throw yourself into the deep end and learn that way - it's an interesting read nonetheless, and I always look forward to your next chapter. Defnitely looking forward to how your next session will go, and how the lessons learned will change your campaign.
Thank you for your kind words. It is always spooky posting personal gaming sessions. A couple of my players have wanted to record them and post them online, but I can't do that! First off, I can't see anybody besides those of us at the table to care, and second, that would make me extremely self conscience. I'm comfortable enough with my players that I'll do dorky stuff, things that I wouldn't feel comfortable doing in public.
Post a Comment