2 days ago
Advanced Dungeons & Dragons BATTLESYSTEM 2nd Edition Review
While wargaming is the grand-daddy of Dungeons &
Dragons, the RPG has evolved separately and quickly became its own entity. By
questioning many of the rules that may seem odd as to how they were formed, the
answers can usually be traced back to our wargaming roots. Ranges, Movement,
combat: All of it heavily borrowed from wargames and evolved to attract a much
larger audience. Some rules are more pronounced than others, for instance the
end-game, mass battles are eluded too in the form of attracting followers and
constructing buildings. The worlds that we create are all hostile to the
players, so the PC’s buildings will no doubt have to be defended from time to
time. War is a common event, however it
was an event that was not officially supported until 1985 with the publication
of BATTLESYSTEM!
In 1989, the year that saw the release of AD&D Second
Edition; before many of the titles which expanded the 2e core system were
released, or even worked on, one of the first 2e products to come out was,
oddly enough, BATTLESYSTEM 2nd Edition. While the BATTLESYSTEM was
always well received within the industry (the original earning the esteemed “H.
G. Wells Award”, and the second edition winning the Origins Award for “Best
Miniatures Rules for 1989”), among consumers it was a different story. Dungeons
& Dragons had tapped into a new audience, and this one wasn’t too hip on
wargames.
Written by Doug Niles, he really didn’t care if there was a
market for this thing or not. All he wanted to do was use the Dungeons and
Dragons magic system within a mass combat game, and when it comes to the 2nd
Edition version, it is safe to say that BATTLESYSTEM 2e would had been
published with or without 2e itself. The original 1985 boxed set contained a
ton of goodies typical of that era; one can almost put it down as a
play-testers box; as the 2e version of the game is polished, containing all of
the changes to the system from feedback that he had gotten, as well as changes
that he had made himself. Gone was the box, the scale of miniatures was
changed, as well as a more streamlined combat system that was easier to manage.
While the booklet was stripped down, its production quality
was improved, it featured glossy, full color pages, pages that were required to
illustrate the fantastic photographs taken by Michael Weaver and Ral Partha Enterprises
INC. While the game wasn’t as demanding
as WARHAMMER in regards to what figure you use, the Ral Partha brand has always
been a well-loved and well-trusted company which players typically stick with
to get their figures anyway.
The booklet contains three stages of play: Basic,
Intermediate, and Advanced.
BASIC PLAY
The Basic rules was just that, a very simple version of the
game that gets players used to moving and understanding what each figure represents.
It is rules light, yet sturdy enough to handle conflicting armies meeting on an
open battle field. When I mean Rules Light, this is kind of an exaggeration;
this game is complicated and hard to learn on your own.
It requires an
investment into the materials needed to play the game, and as many 6 sided dice
as you can afford. You don’t technically need the metal figures to play, that
alone would cost you lots of money and time, and you don’t need to create the
elaborate sets depicted in the book either; but, even going on the cheap is not
an easy task. It is the lucky DM who has the space big enough to host regular
D&D games, this game recommends playing on a Ping Pong table! The larger
the space the better because once a unit leaves the field from failing their
Moral Check, it is gone for good, thus, by using your typical dining room table,
it makes it really hard to regroup your troops before they are off the board.
INTERMEDIATE PLAY
The Intermediate rules add our heroes into the mix, as well
as generals and advanced formations. It doesn’t do a good job of adding the
heroes. If you are thinking about putting your character on the table, you are
putting them in danger beyond anyone’s control. While some will put this as war
is dangerous, I consider placing your PC onto the field as the equivalent of high
stakes gambling; a couple of bad rolls and you are dead, just like that. It had
nothing to do with the decisions that you made, or how aggressive you are
playing, you are dead. Roll up a new character.
Sure, you can be captured, but that kind of depends upon the
enemy, doesn’t it. How many PC parties out there try to capture the biggest
threat in a scenario? Thankfully, you can avoid this by not placing your PC in
the first place, and just controlling the army itself. If you do place your
figure, you can treat it as a King in chess, capture the king and this phase of
the scenario ends and you go back to standard D&D to resolve the situation.
ADVANCED PLAY
The Advanced rules are where all of your fun stuff is. Siege
Engines, Magic, fires, flying troops. Once you’ve mastered the previous
BATTLESYSTEM rule sets, now you are ready to add this stuff to your campaigns!
But, as you can see, that is hard to do. Everyone has to really want this, and
spend game time playing war games scenarios instead of D&D. That isn’t the
only problem with the system either, this is a two player game and Dungeons
& Dragons works best with 4 PCs. You can divide the troops among the party,
or whatever, but it is still a two player game. It doesn’t even need a DM,
though when you are dealing with the Advanced Rule Set, an impartial judge is “desired”.
The game itself is clunky, and more of a board game, and if
you have a difficult time finding players to play standard D&D, you’ll
really enjoy trying to find someone to play this game with you! I have lots of
dedicated players, but only one who has an interest in exploring Mass Combat,
but even then, we’d still rather spend game time playing D&D, not learning
some new ruleset.
APPENDIX
Thankfully, this system is not the only thing that you get
when you buy this book. One can say that the Mass Combat system is just an
added bonus to why you’d buy this thing. Remember the Ral Partha photos I was
talking about? The book provides a wealth of knowledge and hints on not just
how to paint miniatures, but how to modify them, and take care of them. It is a
crash course on a part of the hobby that is very enjoyable to those who have
been bitten by the painting bug. One doesn’t have to spend much money to
partake in it; Ral Partha sells singles that are much cheaper than anti-psychotic
medication and provides the same results (not a qualified medical opinion).
OVERVIEW
Don’t judge this book by its cover (especially this book as
the cover is hideous), it is still a very inexpensive book to own, and something
is better than nothing. There are times when something happens and it just can’t
be resolved any other way! Yes, we can always write around war, or concoct some
house system, which I think is still a viable option, but it is still nice to
have this book as a backup! Those out there that have been able to use this
system say that it is functional, and while it is far from perfect, it is still
the best option to keep that Dungeons & Dragons feel to the game. What it
lacks in the strategy department, it makes up in ease of use and integrating
the magic system. At its root, it is a method of quickly determining the events
which take place during a massive conflict involving many combatants; I just
wish that it was easier to learn.
BTW the Appendix is brilliant, it contains a wealth of quick
reference material, worksheets to create your own units, a method of creating
said units, and The Art of Miniatures section, as I said, is the reason why you
should pick up a copy if you don’t already own one. I give the product a D+.
It begs the question, what do you, the reader do? I suppose
that the most common answer is to ignore it and write around the war, but let’s
just say that it can’t be done. You’ve got to run it, how do you, as a DM
resolve the issue?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
My Blog List
-
My Shoe is Safe - Yesterday's quiz was a toughie. In it, to recap, commenters were encouraged to guess at what the following pieces of art, generated by Substack's own AI ...
-
Fifth-Edition D&D’s Original Lead Designer Calls Out the Game’s “Secret Error” That Remains Today - In fifth edition Dungeons & Dragons, characters and monsters calculate the difficulty class (DC) number needed to save against their spells and powers usin...4 days ago
-
-
La nuova vita di Dungeons&Dragons versione Mentzer! - Ben ritrovati, di recente mi è capitato di leggere su Facebook un commento che mi ha lasciato attonito. In corrispondenza a un post che pubblicizzava un...
1 week ago -
Who Made Blackmoor? A History of Setting Development - In a sense Blackmoor "grew like Topsy", that is to say wild and on its own. Perhaps the first iteration of anything we might call Blackmoor is the well-d...2 weeks ago
-
Banquet For Fools With Game Developers Hannah And Joseph Williams – Episode 281 – 11/26/2024 - Shane Plays Geek Talk Episode #281 – 11/26/2024 Game developers Hannah and Joseph Williams join to chat about their new “Dark Crystal”-like CRPG Banquet ...3 weeks ago
-
All the holidays, all the prices ... (and some news!) - *The short of it is: all my games are on the cheap from now on until January. It is the season, after all. And while I'm here, I might as well talk a bit...
4 weeks ago -
Grimdark vs. Eucatastrophe - Noisms has some interesting ideas in this post about his desire for some depth to his grimdark, and turns to Gene Wolfe and Tolkien for relief. Now, it ...
6 months ago -
Attronarch's Athenaeum - Over at the forum El Borak mentioned Attronarch in his thread Hirelings, loyalty, and morale which you should take a look at. Attronarch has a website Att...9 months ago
-
Last move - to self-hosting! - As my vote regarding Substack in the “marketplace of ideas”, I’m moving to self-hosting. I’m now at (and hopefully staying for a long time at) Blog: ht...11 months ago
-
It's been a decade, now... - This is a tough time of year for me. So, with your indulgence, here's this link to a post I did a decade ago... EDIT: I have no idea why it didn't take. S...2 years ago
-
This Blog is now on Indefinite Hiatus - Greetings, I haven’t been able to post except sporadically for a while. I just found out I will need to find a new place to live within the next few months...3 years ago
-
RIP Christopher Tolkien - LONDON (AP) – Christopher Tolkien, who played a major role protecting the legacy of his father’s The Lord of the Rings series, has died. He was 95. The Tol...4 years ago
-
Sacrifice in the Perilous Realms - Characters sacrifice consumable goods to gods and demons. Characters specify a particular recipient of sacrifice. Characters must find a suitable altar ...4 years ago
-
The Sprawl Session Recaps - For those interested in Actual Play for my campaign of The Sprawl, a Powered by the Apocalypse cyberpunk RPG by Hamish Cameron, I've made a landing page fo...5 years ago
-
Lake Geneva Original RPG Campaign: New EN World Column: #1 - Lake Geneva Original RPG Campaign: New EN World Column: #1: I am now an author for EN World with a monthly column. Six lead columns have been submitted to...5 years ago
-
Blackmoor Week 2019 (9/24/19) - Blackmoor Week and Dave Arneson Game Day running from September 24th through October 1st. This year 2019 is the 45th anniversary of Dungeons & Dragons and ...5 years ago
-
Dave Arneson Blackmoor Week and Game Day 2019 - Blackmoor Week begins today Sept 24, 2019. What are you doing this week to celebrate Dave Arneson's Birthday and his foundational game setting Blackmoor ak...
5 years ago -
Blackmoor Week Day I 2019 - *Blackmoor Week* kicks off today and concludes on October 1st with *Dave Arneson Game Day*. [image: Dave Arneson’s Blackmoor - B-Ware - Sphärenmeisters Spi...5 years ago
-
Basic Land Cannons: Classic and OSR - Basic Land Cannons Threw together some basic cannon rules for a bit of fun carnage. First up: I'm keeping it simple. Cannons are complicated; there are many...
5 years ago -
Character Concepts: Planescape pt 3 - Part 1 Part 2 Continuing my series on oddball Planescape Faction Personalities... Harmonium Sidby the Stick (LG/halfling/fighter) - Sidby's a good enough b...5 years ago
-
Ravensburg Reboot: Streamlined City Map - I mentioned in my last post how I was tweaking and reworking parts of my Ravensburg setting. Today I streamlined the city map. The old map had lots of redu...
5 years ago -
And Now the News Draft Download on Patreon - It's self-styled Throwback Thursday and *having just released the 34-page draft booklet of Hill Cantons news to my Patreon backers* I am going to indulge m...5 years ago
-
Save Versus All Wands Contest: What is the Value of the Coin Hoard? - Treasure Type H Announcing the third annual (well, not quite) Save Versus All Wands contest! You can read about and see the results of the first two - *...
6 years ago -
NIGHTMARES AND SUBURBS: CHARACTER SOCIAL CLASS TABLE - * CHARACTER SOCIAL CLASS * *BACKGROUND TABLE* *I am a big fan of the “Social Origin Roll” for all my player characters in all my g...6 years ago
-
RPGs, Avatar vs Chess Piece Playing - I've gone from DMing AD&D 1E games for friends to my kids to paying clients as a team building tool. I've seen the approaches of playing a character as an...7 years ago
Links to Suggested Stuff
5 comments:
I stumbled on your blog a few weeks ago and I love it! I am currently running a Forgotten Realms campaign set in 1325 DR. I have adapted several 1e modules to 2e. Currently my PC’s are in in the middle of the Desert of Desolation. I have been tweaking it to fit my campaign. After reading this post I am going to introduce a mass combat scenario.
Thanks for the compliments! Mass combat is some hard stuff, but is very interesting. Every table plays D&D differently, and even more so when armies are involved. Typically we always have home brewed quick and messy systems for dealing with it. I'd love to run a "Lord of the Rings" type battle with 10's of thousands involved, however, as written, each figure = 10 men, I figure that if I just do some math I can convert the Movement Rate and scale of the board, however I gave up and just converted humongous war into RISK style combat.
BTW, I really like your site! I did my best to add it to my blog roll, but for whatever reason, it doesn't seem to support the HTML. I'll have to play with some stuff.
> It begs the question, what do you, the reader do? I suppose that the most common answer is to ignore it and write around the war, but let’s just say that it can’t be done. You’ve got to run it, how do you, as a DM resolve the issue?
I take that bull by the horns and scale up and down my games. I've been blogging about it a lot over the past year. I've got two D&D to wargames to D&D sessions with my tabletop group, and one of the same with my 1x1 game with the wife. So far so good.
Sitting in on a table with a grognard like you would definitely help one learn the rules of mass combat! I do enjoy reading all of your posts, but like any blog, it just isn't enough. I kind of feel that any battlesystem must be learned by playing it, which makes it that much harder to learn when that isn't an option.
The player who is interested in the system got a new job, and won't be able to attend our regular games anymore, perhaps he and I can get together here and there and run some of the BATTLESYSTEM scenarios?
I just find systems that work and mess with them. Usually solo play. I'm starting to get more interest from my group, especially a couple of guys who have enjoyed our forays into Book of War.
Post a Comment