2121 Tome of Magic review
The Tome of Magic, I just want to say that I don’t really
care for this book, but I will try my best to give it a fair review. There are those out there
that love this book, and those out there that hate it . . . I am neither. I
have no feelings about this book at all. I bought it years ago and on the rare
occasion that I pick it off of the shelf, I usually set it back down without
finding anything of any value what so ever. I want to say that in all of the
years that I’ve owned it, I have only found one single instance where I used
it, which was last month; that is many many years of gaming, friends. I don’t
know, maybe I’ve used it before and promptly forgot about it, the Tome of Magic
is that kind of book.
It was released in June of 1991, and is the cumulative
effort of David Cook, Nigel Findley,
Anthony Herring, Christopher Kubasik, Carl Sargent, and Rick Swan. It also features some nice art. I always
thought that it was strange for this book to be hardbound, the material found
within it isn’t stuff that you are really going to use all the time, it came
about because Dave Cook thought that there was some holes in the 2e spell list,
which is really kind of crazy, 2nd Edition has some severe bulk
issues when it comes to spells, there are lots of them in the Player’s Handbook
which people complain about because many think of them as throw aways.
CHAPTER I: How to Use Tome
of Magic
In case you don’t know how to use a book, then this section
is for you! Just kidding. This section is very dated, it was written when this
information was brand new and they thought that people wanted to logically
explain why clerics suddenly get new spells that they didn’t have before, which
isn’t relevant anymore. One of the things that it does offer is adding the Wild
Mage to your core rules. Personally, I’ve never really done this. I’m not
opposed to it, it just isn’t anything that has really come up in my campaign.
Looking at them, they look like a DM’s nightmare, I always found NPC wizards
difficult already and I honestly don’t want to deal with even more book work,
maybe it just looks harder than it really is. These rules and alternative
tables look more interesting and more advanced than the version introduced to
us in Forgotten Realms Adventures.*
The Tome also does some modifying to the cleric’s spells and
how they function, specifically in regards to cooperation, which is very
welcome into the game.
CHAPTER II: Wizard’s Spells
None of these spells are all that exciting, but they weren’t
supposed to be. They aren’t spells that are all that useful, or different from
the core spells found in the PHB, except if you specifically write for them,
but there are two camps: Those that want lots of spells, and those that think
that there are just way to many, admittedly I think that there are way to many,
but at least with wizards, there are limits on how many spells that a character
can have, while you want to make sure that the mage has a good balance, it is
nice to have lots of spells to choose from to fill in their lists, but how much
is too much? I suppose that that is a personal question that everybody has to
ask themselves. What really irritates me about the mage is that at 9th
level they can create their own spells, which is difficult when there are so
many spells already out there, however I know that I am nitpicking. When you
are playing a wizard you tend to notice the holes present in the system more
than the Dungeon Master does.
CHAPTER III: Priest Spells
This could had been a mess, but thankfully this book added
new Spheres, for the most part, over just adding spells to the existing ones.
Clerics are hard to play! Especially when magic is required, and this book
tends to make it even more difficult, instead of speed reading one book looking
for ideas for something that you can do, now you have two books to go through.
Another big problem with this section is that the new
spheres aren’t in The Complete Priest’s Handbook, as the Tome was written
afterwards. As a cleric, I generally ignore this thing unless I’ve got a huge
problem. The way that I have found to get around it is through scrolls.
The Tome does offer a concept which they call “Quest Spells”
that are pretty interesting. These are very powerful spells for both PCs and
NPCs which can add story elements that you can’t normally achieve without
ignoring things. I guess to me it is an attractive concept, and it is fairly
well written so that it doesn’t break everything around it. By making
sacrifices you can introduce some awesome concepts to your games which can take
some interesting directions.
While I do have mixed feelings about adding this book as
core to the 2e system, I always end up doing it simply because these spells
have been play-tested, now I’m not afraid to write my own, but that can take a
lot of book work to figure out something that at the end of the day really
doesn’t matter. It is just easier to look through the handbooks for spells, and
when it comes down to writing one, it is nice to have lots of examples to look
at so that you can categorize it properly. What this books spells do do is offer nice and tight mechanics, which I might not be able to achieve on my own.
CHAPTER IV: Magical Items
I never use this chapter, I think that the DMG wastes too
much space with detailing these things, and then you’ve got this book which
adds even more. As a new user, I liked reading sections like these, but as a
well-seasoned DM I find them absolutely worthless. I almost always create my
own magical items for the game, I am stingy when it comes to them and when I
put one into play there is usually a reason.
APPENDIX I-III
These are nice, they collect all of the core spells and categorize
them; there is one for wizards and one for priests, and then an index which cross-references
with the PHB. Now I prefer playing with the old PHB, and I use the first
printing of the Tome of Magic as well, thus this index is accurate, but if you
use the black PHB, unless you have the appropriate version of the Tome, these
page numbers won’t be right.
SUMMARY
This is a popular book, there is no denying that. It saw
many reprints and even reappeared for 3e. It does offer options, but I wish
that it would had offered more than it does. I remember when I first bought
this book I had some expectations and once I got it home and read it, I didn’t
feel that those expectations were met. I
just don’t have much use for this book. I would had liked to see the clerical
magic system reworked, but that never happened until Wizards of the Coast took
over. I probably should use this product more than I do, and I would if I played more magical settings than I typically
run. It would make the NPCs that I create different, but honestly, this has
never been a noticeable problem for me, but that is due to my personal style.
The physical specs of this book are incredible. Because I
used to be a mobile DM, this book was almost always on the bottom of the bag
and took a lot of punishment, which it handled like a champ. It is weird that
it was hardbound, it boosted the price up, but because it was hardbound I think
that more people bought it than normally would had. Typically the hardbound handbooks
are awesome, which personally I don’t feel to be the case here. You can play
the game for the rest of your life and never once need this book. It isn’t even
a very good luxury item. At the time I originally bought it, I felt ripped off
and gave it a D-, but as it has sat on my shelf for many years now, and I do
pick it up from time to time, I can see how this book can spark some creative
slumps, and give a campaign a little bit more color than it normally might, so
I’ll improve this rating to a very shaky C+. This book was written for a
specific market, and I do not fit this market, so admittedly, I’m just a bad judge of this thing because I have little use for
what it offers.
Cost wise, you’ve got to be careful with this one, like I
said before, if this book doesn’t match up with your Players Handbook then you
won’t be able to use the index, which is one of its best features. Don’t trust
pictures, if you use the black PHB you’ll need to buy the ToM printed after
1995, and likewise, any ToM published after 95 won’t match the handbooks
printed before it. PDFs are probably better here, but honestly, this book
really isn’t even needed to play the game so you can skip it unless you find
some cool deal where you can get away with spending 5-10 dollars on the
hardcopy while perusing your favorite used book store.
*EDIT: The Tome of Magic introduces the Wild Mage as a playable character, the concept of Wild Magic was introduced in Forgotten Realms Adventures
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
My Blog List
-
-
Best Books of 2025 - By tradition, December is marked on the 25th by Christmas Day, on the 24th by Christmas Eve, on the 26th by Boxing Day, on the 31st by New Year's Eve, an...5 days ago
-
Making the Best of Roleplaying Games Like Draw Steel and Daggerheart With Player-Driven Turn Orders - The post Turns and Turn Order Are the Worst, so Why Do Roleplaying Games Make Us Spend So Much Time Deliberating Them? compared the two most common methods...5 days ago
-
Heroes of Might and Magic (and Other Goodness) with Neal Hallford – Episode 287 – 11/24/2025 - Shane Plays Geek Talk Episode #287 – 11/24/2025 Neal Hallford joins to discuss his new book Heroes of Might and Magic: 30th Anniversary Retrospective. Th...3 weeks ago
-
Le Regole della Casa del Grognardo: AD&D e il Dual Class - Se c’è una cosa che ha sempre provocato in AD&D una sensazione simile a quella delle unghie che grattano la lavagna sono le regole per i Dual Class. La b...
4 weeks ago -
Ten Friggin Hill Cantons Wizards - 10 Wizards of the Hill Cantons # Name Description 1 Magister Dobromil the Cauterizer Specializes in magical “cleaning” of reality leaks. Wears fou...
1 month ago -
OD&D Denham Tracts Monster Reference - Attacks/Damage in Standard OD&D Style - OD&D Denham Tracts Monster Reference - Attacks/Damage in Standard OD&D Style 1. Alholdes - 1 claw/1d4 2. Apparitions - 1 touch/1d6 (ethereal) 3. Banshee...3 months ago
-
The First Dungeon Crawl in History - Mapping a Lost Session Report, Part II - Today detailed reports from game sessions are common. Until recently, some of the oldest I knew of were to be found in Alarums & Excursions, but only ra...
4 months ago -
Lexicon of Klarkash-Ton, Hierophant of Atlantis: Lupanar - This time, we follow the good High Priest to the far future, to the final continent of Earth, Zothique, for a a tale of ennui and love: Morthylla. Witho...
9 months ago -
STILL ALIVE BITCHES - Well. Here we are again. It's been a while of sickness, needing a wheelchair, and being mostly bed-ridden. SO I do have time for games when I'm not too ...
10 months ago -
DM Style Questionnaire: What are you playing like? - *Hey folks. Quick little post here since I had a discussion with a good friend about the different types of rpg out there and what that means (please tra...
10 months ago -
Last move - to self-hosting! - As my vote regarding Substack in the “marketplace of ideas”, I’m moving to self-hosting. I’m now at (and hopefully staying for a long time at) Blog: ht...1 year ago
-
It's been a decade, now... - This is a tough time of year for me. So, with your indulgence, here's this link to a post I did a decade ago... EDIT: I have no idea why it didn't take. S...3 years ago
-
This Blog is now on Indefinite Hiatus - Greetings, I haven’t been able to post except sporadically for a while. I just found out I will need to find a new place to live within the next few months...4 years ago
-
RIP Christopher Tolkien - LONDON (AP) – Christopher Tolkien, who played a major role protecting the legacy of his father’s The Lord of the Rings series, has died. He was 95. The Tol...5 years ago
-
Sacrifice in the Perilous Realms - Characters sacrifice consumable goods to gods and demons. Characters specify a particular recipient of sacrifice. Characters must find a suitable altar ...5 years ago
-
The Sprawl Session Recaps - For those interested in Actual Play for my campaign of The Sprawl, a Powered by the Apocalypse cyberpunk RPG by Hamish Cameron, I've made a landing page fo...6 years ago
-
Lake Geneva Original RPG Campaign: New EN World Column: #1 - Lake Geneva Original RPG Campaign: New EN World Column: #1: I am now an author for EN World with a monthly column. Six lead columns have been submitted to...6 years ago
-
Blackmoor Week 2019 (9/24/19) - Blackmoor Week and Dave Arneson Game Day running from September 24th through October 1st. This year 2019 is the 45th anniversary of Dungeons & Dragons and ...6 years ago
-
Dave Arneson Blackmoor Week and Game Day 2019 - Blackmoor Week begins today Sept 24, 2019. What are you doing this week to celebrate Dave Arneson's Birthday and his foundational game setting Blackmoor ak...
6 years ago -
Blackmoor Week Day I 2019 - *Blackmoor Week* kicks off today and concludes on October 1st with *Dave Arneson Game Day*. [image: Dave Arneson’s Blackmoor - B-Ware - Sphärenmeisters Spi...6 years ago
-
Character Concepts: Planescape pt 3 - Part 1 Part 2 Continuing my series on oddball Planescape Faction Personalities... Harmonium Sidby the Stick (LG/halfling/fighter) - Sidby's a good enough b...6 years ago
-
Ravensburg Reboot: Streamlined City Map - I mentioned in my last post how I was tweaking and reworking parts of my Ravensburg setting. Today I streamlined the city map. The old map had lots of redu...
6 years ago -
Save Versus All Wands Contest: What is the Value of the Coin Hoard? - Treasure Type H Announcing the third annual (well, not quite) Save Versus All Wands contest! You can read about and see the results of the first two - *...
7 years ago -
NIGHTMARES AND SUBURBS: CHARACTER SOCIAL CLASS TABLE - * CHARACTER SOCIAL CLASS * *BACKGROUND TABLE* *I am a big fan of the “Social Origin Roll” for all my player characters in all my g...7 years ago
-
RPGs, Avatar vs Chess Piece Playing - I've gone from DMing AD&D 1E games for friends to my kids to paying clients as a team building tool. I've seen the approaches of playing a character as an...8 years ago
Links to Suggested Stuff
2 comments:
Not sure how you review the TOM without a proper covering of the new classes- the Wild Mage & Elementalists... Which were the main things I or most people seem to have used from the book.
Aside from the odd spell- which I sometimes used, the new classes were noticeably different and allowed a totally different campaign style/feel than the usual "schools' format.
Want a new continent/alien spell casting tradition- boom, here's your "go to", just dress it up however you like.
One of only two 2e splatbooks which ever saw much use IMC, along with the CB of Humanoids.
That actually sounds cool. I never played these new classes, nor have any of my players. I always found Wizards to be the most difficult to play, they are very hard to figure out and I don't think that we ever really got good enough where we felt the need to expand the schools.
Well, I've had/have a couple of players that are really good at it, but they prefer to play general wizards. I was able to talk one of them into playing a specialist after altering my Forgotten Realms setting to eliminate general wizards, just to see how that would go, but that is as far as we ever got to really exploring the schoolmen concept. I will admit that I'm in favor of keeping it.
Post a Comment